Pegasus Restaurant Menu
191 items in 26 sections · $2.00 – $36.00 · Greek Restaurant in Milwaukee, WI
Pegasus Restaurant’s menu lists 191 dishes and drinks, grouped into From the Broiler, Mexican, Garden Fresh Salads, Breakfast Combo, Omelets, and Thanksgiving Specials and more. Prices range from $2.00 to $36.00, and a typical item costs about $14.00. Popular choices include New York USDA Choice Strip Steak 10 Oz., Cheese Only Quesadilla, Apple Walnut Chicken Salad, Old Town, and Farmers Omelet.
From the Broiler 5
- New York USDA Choice Strip Steak 10 Oz.$23.00
America’s favorite steak! This cut is aged for flavor, broiled to order and served with sautéed mushrooms.
- Broiled Center Cut Pork Chops$13.00
Two juicy, center cut pork chops, broiled and served with a side of apple sauce
- • Sirloin Steak USDA Choice 8 Oz.$18.00
Served with sautéed mushrooms.
- Broiled Chicken Breast 7-8 Oz.$14.50
Our steaks and chops are lightly seasoned
- Chopped Sirloin Steak$16.00
Ground beef steak, char-broiled topped with grilled onions.
Mexican 5
- Cheese Only Quesadilla$11.00
Grilled flour tortillas, filled with cheese, diced green peppers, tomatoes, onions and your choice of meat.
- Fajitas$17.50
Char-grilled USDA choice sirloin strips, chicken or shrimp, onions, tomatoes and green peppers. Served up with warm flour tortillas, shredded cheese, sour cream and salsa
- Tacos Trio$12.00
Three flour tortillas filled your choice of meat or fish mildly seasoned, topped with lettuce, tomatoes, and shredded cheese. Served with rice, beans, sour cream & salsa.
- Enchiladas$18.50
Fresh corn tortillas stuffed with your choice of chicken or beef topped with our own enchilada sauce, cheddar cheese. Served with rice and beans, sour cream & salsa.
- • Steak & Shrimp Fajita Combo$23.00
Char-grilled strips of sirloin and spicy grilled shrimp, onions, tomatoes and green peppers, served up with warm flour tortillas, shredded cheese, sour cream and salsa.
Garden Fresh Salads 11
- Apple Walnut Chicken Salad$16.50
Grilled chicken breast, apples, mandarin oranges, bleu cheese crumbles, and walnuts.
- Taco Salad$14.00
Spicy ground beef, black olives, onions, tomatoes, Cheddar cheese, over fresh greens in a crispy tortilla bowl, served with sour cream and salsa.
- Strawberry Chicken Breast Salad$17.00
Grilled chicken breast, mandarin oranges, fresh strawberries, blueberries, and pecans. Served with poppy seed dressing.
- California Fruit Plate$14.50
Chilled assorted fresh seasonal fruit platter, served with a scoop of cottage cheese and raisin toast Additional charges with Chicken breast
- Chef Salad$16.00
Fresh roasted turkey, roast beef, ham, American & Swiss cheese, tossed with crisp greens, tomatoes, cucumbers, onions and sliced hard boiled egg.
- Lo-Cal Stuffed Tomato$14.50
Ripe tomato stuffed with your choice of tuna or chicken salad, served with cottage cheese, hard boiled egg, fresh fruit and whole wheat toast.
- Cobb Salad$16.00
Mixed greens, tender grilled chicken breast, bleu cheese, black olives, tomatoes, shredded Cheddar cheese, chopped egg, real bacon crumbles and your choice of dressing
- Fruit Bowl$11.50
Seasonal fresh fruit and raisin toast.
- Caesar Salad$11.50
Fresh Romaine lettuce, tossed with croutons, Parmesan cheese and Caesar dressing. Additional charged with shrimp, chicken or steak.
- Chunky Chicken Salad$14.00
Crisp greens with a scoop of chicken salad topped with pineapple, strawberries and pecans
- My Big Fat Greek Salad$14.00
Crisp greens, feta cheese, Greek olives, tomatoes, pepperoncini, chopped onions, topped with anchovies and served with our homemade Greek dressing. Additional charges With Chicken or With Gyro Meat.
Breakfast Combo 15
- Old Town$14.50
Two eggs any style, sliced kielbasa sausage topped with melted Swiss cheese, diced green peppers & onions. Served with potatoes and toast.
- Breakfast Croissant$13.50
Two farm fresh eggs, bacon and American cheese. Served with potatoes.
- Breakfast Burrito$15.50
Eggs scrambled with spicy ground beef, green peppers, onions, jalapeños and cheddar cheese all wrapped in a flour tortilla. Served with potatoes, side of salsa and sour cream.
- Corned Beef Hash & Eggs$15.50
Corned beef hash, two farm fresh eggs, potatoes and toast.
- Double Header$13.50
Two pancakes, two eggs any style with your choice of bacon, sausage links or ham.
- Pegasus Favorite$18.00
Two farm fresh eggs served with one broiled pork chop, potatoes and toast.
- Chicken Fried Steak & Eggs$15.50
Breaded and fried to perfection, topped with country gravy, two farm fresh eggs, potatoes and toast.
- 10 Oz. New York USDA Choice Steak & Eggs$21.00
America's favorite steak, two eggs any style, potatoes and toast.
- French Toast Combo$14.50
One slice of thick French toast, two strips of bacon, two sausage links and two egg any style.
- Steak And Eggs$18.50
A flavorful house 8 oz. sirloin steak, two eggs any style, potatoes and toast.
- Breakfast Quesadilla$15.00
Ham, onions, tomatoes, green peppers, scrambled eggs, and cheddar cheese. Served with potatoes, side of salsa and sour cream.
- The All American$13.50
Two strips of bacon, two sausage links, two eggs any style, potatoes and toast.
- House Special$17.00
Three farm fresh eggs served with tender gyro meat, potatoes and three slices of toast.
- Old Fashioned Oatmeal$5.50
Slow cooked oatmeal served with raisins and brown sugar.
- Country Biscuit Platter$14.50
Biscuits and gravy, sausage patties, two eggs any style and potatoes. No toast.
Omelets 9
- Farmers Omelet$15.00
Diced ham, mushrooms, onions, green peppers and American cheese.
- Avocado Bacon Omelet$15.50
Fresh avocado, bacon and tomatoes.
- Vegetarian Omelet$13.50
Mushrooms, broccoli, onions, tomatoes, green peppers and Swiss cheese.
- Denver Omelet$13.00
Ham, onions and peppers.
- Cheese Omelet$10.50
- Feta Cheese & Spinach Omelet$12.50
- Mexican Omelet$16.00
Onions, tomatoes, chorizo, salsa, jalapeños and cheddar cheese. Served with a side of sour cream.
- Greek Omelet$15.50
Gyro meat, onions, tomatoes and feta cheese.
- Ham Omelet$12.50
Thanksgiving Specials 5
- Ham & Turkey Combo$18.50
Ham & Turkey Combo Plate.
- Tenderloin Tips$18.50
Tenderloin Tips Over Buttered Noodles (No Potato)
- Turkey Special$18.50
Roast Turkey with Sage Dressing, Sweet Potatoes, Confetti Corn, Mashed Potatoes, Turkey Gravy and Cranberry Sauce.
- Ham & Sweet Potatoes$16.00
Baked Honey Ham with Sweet Potatoes.
- Scalloped Potatoes And Ham$17.50
Scalloped Potatoes and Ham.
Desserts 6
- Sundaes$7.50
Hot fudge, strawberry, pineapple.
- Brownies$5.00
- Shakes Or Malts$7.00
- Banana Split$9.50
- Ice Cream$4.00
- Tapioca Pudding$5.50
Burgers 6
- • Classic Burger$10.00
Freshly ground, hand formed and grilled to perfection
- • Avocado Bacon Cheeseburger$15.00
Topped with sliced avocado, crispy bacon strips, and American cheese.
- • Hickory Burger$14.00
Topped with cheddar cheese, bacon, and Sweet Baby Rays BBQ sauce.
- • Western Burger$15.00
Topped with pepper jack cheese, bacon, fried onion strings and jalapeño peppers.
- • The Hangover Burger$16.00
Topped with a fried egg, American cheese, bacon, red onions, lettuce, tomato, and mayo.
- • South Of The Border Burger$15.50
Topped with pepper jack cheese, bacon, avocado, and pico de gallo.
Combos 3
- BBQ Ribs & 4 Breaded Jumbo Shrimp$25.00
- BBQ Ribs & Rotisserie Or Broasted Chicken$23.00
- * 8oz. Sirloin Steak & 4 Breaded Jumbo Shrimp$23.00
Breakfast 7
- Avocado & Bacon Eggs Benedict$16.00
Two poached eggs on a toasted English muffin, avocado and bacon. Topped with traditional hollandaise sauce. Served with potatoes.
- Avocado Toast$13.50
Freshly smashed avocado on toasted multigrain, eggs any style, topped with everything bagel seasoning.
- Overpowered Avocado Toast$15.00
Freshly smashed avocado on grilled sourdough with sunny side up eggs, tomatoes, feta cheese, everything bagel seasoning, Topped with our balsamic glaze.
- Homestyle Benedict$14.50
Two poached eggs on a toasted biscuit, sausage patties and sausage gravy. Served with potatoes.
- Eggs Benedict$13.50
Two poached eggs on a toasted English muffin, Canadian bacon and traditional hollandaise sauce. Served with potatoes.
- Two Eggs Any Style$8.00
Two farm fresh eggs served with potatoes and toast.
- California Eggs Benedict$14.00
Two poached eggs on a toasted English muffin, tomatoes, spinach and cream cheese. Topped with traditional hollandaise sauce. Served with potatoes.
Wings 5
- 6 Wings$8.50
- 10 Wings$13.50
- 20 Wings$23.50
- 15 Wings$19.50
- 35 Wings$36.00
Club Sandwiches 6
- Ham & Cheese Club$13.00
- Turkey Avocado BLT Club$14.50
Sliced turkey breast, fresh avocado, bacon, lettuce, and tomato.
- Turkey Club$12.00
- House Club$14.00
Ham, turkey, Swiss & American cheese.
- Chicken Avocado Club$15.50
Avocado, Chicken breast, bacon & Swiss cheese served on toasted sourdough bread
- B.L.T Club$12.00
New Year’s Day Specials 3
- Beef Burgundy$18.50
Over Buttered Noodles. Served with Soup or Salad.
- Blackened Tilapia$21.00
Sautéed Vegetables and Mashed Potatoes. Topped with Two Grilled Shrimp over Jambalaya Sauce. Served with a Cup of Soup or Salad.
- Ham & Turkey Combo Plate$18.50
Served with Sage Dressing, Confetti Corn, Mashed Potatoes, and Cranberry Sauce. Your Choice of Soup or Salad.
Beverages 8
- Tea$3.50
- Juice$3.00
Orange, Apple, Cranberry, and Tomato.
- Soda$4.00
- Milk$3.00
- Coffee$3.50
- Sprecher Root Beer (Bottle)$6.00
- Lemonade$4.00
- Hot Chocolate$4.00
Extras 16
- Feta Cheese$5.00
- Hot Chili$5.00
- Hollandaise Sauce$3.00
- Baked Or Mashed Potato$4.00
- Waffle Fries$4.50
- Gyro Meat$8.00
- Onion Rings$5.00
- Cottage Cheese$4.50
With peach halves.
- BBQ Sauce$2.00
- French Fries$4.00
- Tossed Salad$5.50
- Gravy$2.50
- Baked French Onion Soup$6.00
Served in a crock with melted Mozzarella cheese
- Scoop Of Chicken Or Tuna Salad$9.00
Served with fresh fruit
- Steamed Broccoli$4.00
- Soup Du Jour$4.50
Available after 11 am. sunday - cream of chicken rice / minestrone monday - chicken noodle / cream of potato with bacon tuesday - navy bean / chicken dumpling wednesday - chicken rice / italian wedding thursday - split pea / chicken rosamar
Deli Style Sandwiches 19
- French Dip Sandwich$13.00
Thinly sliced beef piled high on toasted ciabatta bread and served with Au Jus for dipping.
- Chicken Or Tuna Salad Sandwich$11.00
Our healthy, tasty scoop of homemade tuna or chicken salad, served on your choice of bread.
- • Patty Melt$13.00
Topped with grilled onions and melted American cheese, served on grilled marble rye bread.
- Chicken Cordon Bleu$14.00
A grilled chicken breast topped with deli sliced ham and melted Mozzarella cheese, served on a toasted bun.
- Reuben Sandwich$14.00
Grilled tender corned beef, mounded on marble rye and topped with tangy sauerkraut and Swiss cheese.
- Grilled Or Fried Chicken Breast$12.00
Broiled chicken breast, served open-faced on toasted focaccia bread.
- Fish Sandwich$14.00
A deep fried fillet of fish, served on a toasted bun with tartar sauce
- Grilled Cheese$8.00
Your choice of Swiss, American, Monterey Jack, or Pepper Jack cheese.
- • 8 Oz. Choice Sirloin Steak Sandwich$17.00
House sirloin served on toast and cooked just the way you like it!
- Tuna Melt$12.00
Served on grilled marble rye bread with American cheese.
- B.L.T.$10.50
Bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayo, served on white toast.
- Texas BBQ Chicken Sandwich$14.00
Shredded chicken breast on Texas toast with grilled onions, Mozzarella cheese and BBQ sauce.
- Aussie Chicken Sandwich$14.00
Chicken breast topped with crispy bacon, mushrooms, melted Jack cheese and cheddar cheeses. Served on a ciabatta bread.
- Monterey Chicken$15.00
Grilled chicken breast with crispy bacon, melted Monterey Jack cheese and ranch dressing on toasted focaccia bread.
- • 10 Oz. New York USDA Choice Steak Sandwich$21.50
Tender and flavorful cut from the finest of beef, served on toasted ciabatta bread, cooked to your liking and garnished with red onions and a tomato slice.
- Philly Cheese Steak$15.00
A hearty serving of thinly sliced beef, topped with onions, green peppers, mushrooms, and melted Swiss cheese. Served on ciabatta bread.
- Monte Cristo$15.00
Ham, turkey, Swiss cheese, grilled between two thick French toast slices.
- Gyro Sandwich$14.00
Tender gyro meat carved off the spit, wrapped in pita bread with onions and tomatoes. Gyro sauce served on the side.
- Kickin’ Chicken$14.50
Char-broiled chicken breast with bacon, cheddar cheese, avocado, and Chipotle Mayo. Served on ciabatta bread.
Stir Fry 4
- Chicken Stir Fry$16.50
Mildly seasoned chicken chunks combined with Oriental style vegetables and served over a bed of rice.
- Veggie Stir Fry$13.50
A delectable combination of fresh Oriental style vegetables and served over a bed of rice.
- Shrimp Stir Fry$19.00
Choice bay shrimp combined with select Oriental style vegetables and served over a bed of rice.
- • Steak Stir Fry$19.00
Mildly seasoned chunks of steak combined with Oriental style vegetables and served over a bed of rice.
Pancakes, Waffles & Sweet Selections 8
- Crepes Plain (3)$10.50
- Fried Chicken & Waffles$18.00
- Polar Bear Waffle$17.50
With butter pecan ice cream, strawberries, bananas and whipped cream.
- Buttermilk Pancakes$9.00
- Two Slices Of Thick Or Thin French Toast$12.50
- Swedish Crepes (3)$14.00
Filled with our homemade creamy cinnamon sauce, topped with Lingonberries.
- Belgian Waffle$11.00
- Pecan Waffle$12.50
Seafood 7
- Fish Fry (4) Pieces$16.00
12 oz. cod loin Beer Battered or Original. Served with coleslaw and tartar sauce.
- Breaded Jumbo Shrimp$19.50
Eight lightly breaded jumbo shrimp, deep fried and served with cocktail sauce and coleslaw.
- Tilapia Broiled Or Fried$17.50
Fresh broiled or Fried tilapia fillet with grilled vegetables.
- Jambalaya$21.00
Shrimp, chicken, sausage, sautéed with onions, tomatoes and peppers in a spicy tomato Cajun sauce over fresh pasta or rice.
- Salmon$19.50
A fresh 8 oz. Salmon filet served with lightly seasoned & grilled onions, broccoli, cauliflower, green and red peppers.
- Catfish Filet$17.50
Broiled catfish fillet served with rice pilaf and lightly seasoned & grilled fresh vegetables.
- Cod$16.00
12 oz. cod loin broiled with lemon butter sauce and fresh vegetables.
Hot Sandwiches 1
- Hot Sandwiches$14.00
Meat Loaf or Roast Turkey
Greek Favorites 4
- Gyro Platter$18.00
Sliced gyro meat fresh off the cone, tomatoes, onions, open face on a warm pita. Served with a side of feta cheese, olives, sliced green peppers and seasoned with oregano.
- Athenian Style Chicken Breast And Gyro Meat Combination$19.50
Served with rice pilaf and topped with Athenian sauce.
- (2) Greek Style Pork Chops$19.50
Two center cut broiled pork chops, seasoned with oregano, garlic and olive oil. Served with Athenian sauce.
- Greek Style Chicken Breast$15.00
Rice pilaf topped with Athenian sauce, served with fresh broccoli.
House Specialties 8
- Meat Loaf$15.50
The old fashioned favorite, sliced thick and served hot.
- 1/2 Broasted Chicken$16.50
Juicy chicken, slow broasted. Add white meat for additional charges.
- BBQ Baby Back Ribs$18.00
Slow cooked pork ribs brushed with baby rays barbecue sauce.
- Beef Liver$14.50
Pan fried with lots of grilled onions.
- Roast Turkey$16.00
Hand carved turkey breast, served with dressing and cranberry sauce.
- Chicken Fried Steak$16.50
Served with country gravy.
- 1/2 Rotisserie Chicken$16.50
Juicy chicken, slow broasted. Add white meat for additional charges.
- Ham Steak$14.50
Topped with pineapple rings.
Breakfast Side Orders 12
- Kielbasa Sausage$7.00
- One Egg$2.50
- Toast$2.50
- Corned Beef Hash$7.50
- Pecan Roll$5.00
- Fresh Fruit Cup$3.50
- Egg Beaters$4.00
- One Pancake$4.50
- Breakfast Potatoes$4.00
- Biscuits & Gravy$7.50
- Bagel With Cream Cheese$5.00
- Breakfast Meat$4.50
Skillets 7
- Greek Skillet$15.50
Gyro meat, onions, tomatoes and feta cheese.
- Bacon & Onion Skillet$13.00
Bacon, onions and cheddar cheese.
- Chicken Skillet$14.50
Chicken, diced onions, tomatoes, green peppers, mushrooms and cheddar cheese.
- Meat Lovers Skillet$16.50
For the meat lover! ham, sausage, bacon and cheddar cheese.
- Steak Skillet$16.50
USDA sirloin, mushrooms, onions and cheddar cheese.
- Farmers Skillet$14.50
Diced ham, onions, green peppers, mushrooms, topped with cheddar cheese.
- Kielbasa Sausage Skillet$15.00
Kielbasa slices, onions, green peppers & cheddar cheese.
Italian Pastas 5
- Baked Lasagna$16.00
Scrumptious layers of pasta, cheese and seasoned ground beef with marinara sauce.
- Spaghetti & Meatballs$16.00
“The Original“ Spaghetti served with our own marinara sauce and two large homemade meatballs.
- Pasta A La Roma$18.00
Tender cuts of chicken breast on top of spinach and fettuccine pasta with fresh broccoli and sliced fresh mushrooms in Alfredo sauce.
- Fettuccini Alfredo$13.00
The classic creamy combination of cheese and cream sauce over fettuccine noodles.
- Chicken Parmesan$17.00
Tender breaded chicken breast, topped with marinara and melted Mozzarella cheese, served over spaghetti.
Starters 6
- Mozzarella Sticks (7)$9.50
- Appetizer Sampler$16.00
Mozzarella sticks, chicken tenders, cheese quesadillas.
- Cheese Curds$9.50
With ranch dressing.
- Onion Rings$9.00
Everyone’s Favorite!.
- Chicken Tenders$11.00
Served with a choice of BBQ sauce or ranch dressing.
- Haystack Onions$9.00
Menu items and prices are provided for information and may have changed (last updated May 2026). Allergen information is not included – please ask the restaurant.